Posts Tagged ‘Olympics’

Bizarre Refereeing and the Fixers

Tuesday, August 7th, 2012

Dear Friends and Colleagues,

The e-mail inbox is full, once again, with requests for comments on two controversial stories that have just broken in England.

Canada vs. the United States women’s Olympic semi-final: a superb match, marred with some bizarre refereeing. One extraordinary set of decisions led directly to the U.S’s equalizing goal. Canadian journalists have been demanding to know if ‘the fix was in’?

I try to never make remarks about possible corruption in matches that I simply watch. To be a referee is a pretty thankless task. Everyone is capable of making mistakes (when was the last time you got 100% on an exam?). So unless I have compelling first-hand evidence of bribes being passed, I never say if a match has been fixed simply from watching it. For me, it is matter of credibility. What I say normally about certain matches being fixed or the gang of fixers still being in operation is controversial enough.

This brings me to the second story – Chris Eaton (former FIFA head of security) has finally came out and confirmed that what I said before, during and after the South Africa World Cup in 2010 is true. There were people trying to fix matches at the tournament. They were focusing on the African teams. They were operating even after I exposed their activities two years before that in The Fix.

A number of points:

Much of the actual story of what went on in South Africa Chris leaves out.

I was hampered from exposing the complete truth at that time in South Africa by a couple of moronic British journalists, (a shocking story for anyone who believes in a tough, rigorous fourth estate. I write about it in my upcoming book).

It has taken Eaton two years to reveal the story of the fixers. We simply cannot rely on the officials or the regular sports media to properly protect the game that we love. We need an international anti-corruption agency to make sure the fixers are stopped cold and when we see bizarre refereeing in the future, we simply think that it is an accident not corruption.

Share

What Can I Possibly Say?

Friday, August 3rd, 2012

In a writer’s lock-down finishing a draft of the next book. Occasionally, I watch Olympic events from my beloved sports: football, rowing and boxing. But my inbox has been full this week of people asking for comments and interviews on the recent fixing in badminton. I try to keep my blog and twitter feed for only original comment. (My view of social media is that it is only good when you have something interesting to say, so I try to make sure that I say too little rather than too much.) However, there have been so many requests, I will post something now.

To review – in case you have been locked-away in a non-Olympic spot somewhere on the planet – this week the badminton world was treated to the unedifying spectacle of eight players deliberating trying to lose to make sure their next games in the tournament were easier.

The whole thing was such a farce, such an example of everything disrespectful of sport and fair play it is genuinely difficult to think of anything to say except express contempt for the players and their coaches and administrators who ordered them to act in such a way.

A few thoughts:

1) The Badminton officials did the right thing by disqualifying the athletes. Good for them. Tough decision. Well done.

2) There have been a few commentators who have spectacularly missed the point by claiming that it is the sports officials fault for organizing a tournament in this fashion. These “journalists” claim that it makes sense for intelligent athletes to get as far as they can in tournaments by fixing and cheating. It is difficult not to laugh at such stupidity from professional sporting pundits.

3) In recent years, no Chinese athlete ever did anything without being explicitly ordered to by their coaches and officials. The Chinese athletic organizations have been fixing and cheating for years in the sports that they dominate like table tennis and badminton. They fix and cheat in order to make sure that the Chinese continue to dominate, by resting their athletes and giving them easy games.

Are there any independent-minded Chinese athletes? Yes, of course. But they are currently running laps around dusty tracks in outer Tibet or suffering some worse punishment for daring to have a life, not take the prescribed pills or trying to win games that their coaches have told them to lose.

The Chinese sports world is dominated by a bunch of criminally-minded thugs who think that all athletic achievement is a reflection, not of their wonderful culture and country, but a political party that has murdered more people than anyone else in history. Losing the odd badminton match is not going to embarrass or stop these sports officials.

4) Given this context there is one thing more that badminton officials need to do – stop any country from entering more than one set of athletes for each event. After all, in the World Cup, you do not have four teams from Brazil or Argentina playing. In rowing, you do not have two Canadian teams of eight racing against each other. The advantage to this format, is that the Chinese would continue to be very good in these sports – all credit to their athletes – but it would generate more worldwide interest for these sports.

5) Until those changes are done, stand-by for more fixing.

Share

Will the fixers be at the London Games?

Tuesday, July 24th, 2012

Yes, of course they will be there. Why would they not be? We know they have been at every major international soccer tournament (with the exception of the Euros) in the last twenty years: under-17, under-20, Women’s World Cup, Men’s World Cup and the Olympics. We know this because not only did I interview the fixers but also numerous coaches, players and sports officials who confirmed seeing the fixers at the events. What we do not know is if they will succeed at fixing any games.

I do not say this lightly. I did not issue a similar warning before the Euros, but I did in the run-up to the South Africa World Cup. Few people chose to heed the warning. Now we know that four of the five friendly matches played by the South African team were arranged by a fixer run company. We know that the fixers were at the Athens Olympics. We know that they were active in China during the Women’s World Cup. We know that they have been operating across Asia, Europe, Africa and Central America. We know that there are numerous national police investigations into their activities, yet only one Asian member of their gang has actually been arrested. So knowing all those facts, the question becomes not whether the fixers will be at the Games, but why would they not be there?

Surely, no athlete would want to ruin their chances of Olympic glory?

Try not to be naïve. In the Olympic soccer tournament there are only a few teams that have any chance of gaining a medal, let alone winning the whole thing. Any realist connected with sport knows that fact. They also know that the players will be running into sold-out stadiums, the games will be broadcast to hundreds of millions of people around the world and that someone, somewhere, is making a lot of money from the sponsors, but that often those people are not the athletes who are actually playing the game. Add to this that many of the athletes and referees are poor people from poor countries who have few chances in their careers to make good money and when they do, often their own sports officials deprive them of a proper reward.

This is the key dynamic that drives sports corruption – exploitation of the players/referees – until it stops fixers can reasonably expect that some of the athletes/referees will listen to them.

Just a second, I read in the newspapers that the London Games and the International Olympic Committee had a special security squad to stop the fixers?

LOL. Oh dear, oh dear, oh dear! [Sound of Hill falling off chair with laughter] The London Games’ security? I think we all know that is an oxymoron now. The private company that had the contract to ‘secure’ the Games announced two weeks ago that they had not found enough guards. In the training sessions for some of the guards that they did find, some were asleep and a few had no idea of how to ‘secure’ the Games after their training sessions. The UK Customs and Border security staff are also holding a one-day strike this week, which should add to the general feeling of security that any fixer or dodgy customer feels when flying into the London Games.

Units of the British Army have been drafted in at the last moment, which is good (although unfair to the soldiers, who should have had months of preparation). But most of their attention has gone to preventing potential terrorist attacks, not stopping the odd rich gambler who may be entering the country.

But, I remember in March that spokespeople for the British gambling industry announced, after meeting with the IOC and London organizers, that no one had anything to worry about – few people bothered betting on the Olympics so it was not worth fixing any of the events.

Oh they did, did they? This would be the same industry that is now taking bets on just about every conceivable aspect of the Games from whether there will be daily rain showers at the Olympic Stadium (50/1) to who will win the Women’s Badminton Final to whether the Olympic Village will run out of condoms (7/2).

To be fair, the fixers usually do not bet with the British gambling industry. It is simply too well-regulated and monitored. What they do is bet on the Asian – largely illegal -gambling market. Everyone in the betting industry knows this, so quite how some of their spokesmen were able to say what they did in March with a straight face is beyond me.

Could the fixers be stopped?

Yes, of course. Ideally, the campaign against them should have begun months ago. The fixers have probably already traveled to visit most of their regular athletes/referees contacts in their own countries to set up any potential deals. However, even now someone could stop the fixers cold, but with the level of disorganization that we have seen, do not hold your breath on that happening.

So with a few days to go before the start of the Olympics, we are, as usual, forced to rely on two things: the honesty of every single athlete and referee and the knowledge that if a fix did actually occur few people – not the fixers, complicit athletes/referees or sports officials – have any interest in publicizing that fact. It is not a reassuring situation.

Share

70,000 Copies of the ‘The Fix’ and the Prosecutor Who is Cleaning the Stables

Saturday, July 2nd, 2011

If you speak Greek and want a free copy of ‘The Fix’ – get to Athens this weekend. There, one of the top newspapers Ethnos is featuring a full-feature interview with me and giving away copies of the book for the first 70,000 people who buy the newspaper.

This is all happening because last Wednesday, just before I was to testify at the Council of Europe in Strasbourg, a young, dynamic, female prosecutor Popi Papandreou did what few men in Greek sports would have done and arrested 68 top football officials including the President of the Greek Super-League and head of the Olympiakos. She arrested them because she accused them of sustained and systematic match-fixing and corruption.

A brief explanation for non-Greeks – this is like arresting the head of the Premier League and Manchester United, dozens of players and other senior football officials in one swoop. It is a massive hammer blow against corruption. It is the cleaning of the Augean stables of Greek sport. Now of course, some of the people arrested will be found innocent, but Ms. Papandreou was backed, not only by the Greek state police but also by their national secret service. She had led this law enforcement team for 10-months and they produced a 124-page prosecution report to justify the arrests. And at the beginning of that report, Ms. Papendrou was kind enough to declare that ‘The Fix’ had been her intellectual guide to follow the trails of corruption in Greek sport.

Since the release of the prosecution report, I have been overwhelmed with requests from Greek media and this is why the complete copies of ‘The Fix’ are to be issued in a special edition of ‘Ethnos’. However, below is an excerpt from one of those interviews (in English) and for Greek speakers a link is here to another:

**

1) Are you surprised that Greece is so much involved in a case like this? If not, why?

Not particularly, Greek football has been renown for corruption for a long time.

2) Do you remember when it was the first time that you heard of Greece and set up games?

It was very commonplace to hear about fixed matches in Greek football. When I spoke to the fixers they discussed the sport in your country as if were the Balkans, a lawless place where the criminals ran the place and the good men were kept in the ditches.

3) Were you anxious by the fact that until now nothing had happened in Greece from the authorities?

I was not surprised that nothing had been done by the authorities. But I am now delighted that finally someone is standing up for Greek sports and showing courage to defend the future for your young people.

4) Could you remember a specific name of person or team that you heard during your research in Asia or in any other place?

The main focus of my research and my book was infiltrating a gang of fixers who travel to every single big international soccer tournament – the under-17 World Cup, the under-20 World Cup, the Women’s World Cup, the Olympic soccer tournament and the World Cup itself.

They have approached dozens of teams and hundreds of players and referees over the last twenty years. I got into the gang. I wore a hidden camera and taped some of their meetings. Then I exposed their activities in the book. So I could not spare any time to focus on any other leagues or matches, including Greece.

However, I do know that the fixers were at the Athens Olympics in 2004 and were approaching players and paying them. This has been confirmed not only by the fixers but by players and coaches at the tournament. It is all in the book.

5) All over he world, almost every day, we are informed for set up games… Is there a solution for that very big problem of sports?

Match-fixing is the biggest problem for sport. Once it loses credibility it is very difficult to regain it.

However, there are lots of ways to defend against corruption in sport. Ironically, it is very easy because corruption in sports happens right in front of people, unlike most corruption which occurs in locked rooms.

What we need now is an international anti-corruption agency, like the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA), to fight against this international problem.

6) Do you consider Greece as one of the most corrupted country all over the world in sports?

Gosh no! The corruption in Greek sports may be quite bad (and remember some of the people who were arrested may be found innocent), however, it is nothing like the level of corruption in the Asian countries. There the politicians describe levels of corruption of over fifty percent of the matches being fixed. So it is more normal for a fan to see a fixed match than a normally played match.

Greece is bad, but it has not reached anywhere near those levels.

7) I would like to describe me your feelings by the time that those men of the Chinese betting baron, approached you, transferred you in front of him till the end? It was scary I suppose, but could you describe those feelings with words? And finally why did he do that with you? It was a power festival for him?

I remember the first time I met one of the fixers, it was at a private golf course late at night. He was on the phone getting information about fixes in a number different countries (including a possible one in the German Bundesliga). I was both terrified and fascinated. Finally, after an hour of conversation, I asked, ‘What is the biggest game you have ever fixed?’

He looked at me and said, ‘I don’t know. Which is bigger the Olympics or the World Cup?’

I told him, very, very politely, that I did not believe that he could fix a match at such a high-level and he said, ‘Alright, watch me.’

This is the essential story of ‘The Fix’. How for the next few months I watched them as they held meetings to fix really top-level games.

8 ) Do you have an opinion about basketball… Is it corrupted as football?

I try not to speculate about sports when I do not have all the facts. What I say is controversial enough, so I need to guard my credibility and only speak about sports that I am an expert on.

9) What is the key point to set up a game? What is the procedure,  I mean the way to do it? Players? Coaches? Presidents? Referees?

Imagine, that a fixer is like a spider in the centre of his web. The net goes in two directions, the first, is obviously into the sport – to players and referees, and sometimes club owners – to underperform and thus, lose their games. However, there is a second direction, that is into the gambling market. Good fixers have to hide their activities in the market otherwise the fix is too obvious. They employ companies and other people to disguise their fixing.

What does this mean in real life? Well, one of the myths about fixing is that it is always the strong team losing to a weak team and thus the fixer makes a big profit on the market. Actually, it is much more common for a fixer to fix a weak team playing against a strong team. Generally, weak teams are badly paid, so the players or club owners are cheaper. Generally, no one suspects anything if the weak team loses, so the odds in the market do not change. And generally, because it is cheap and no one has noticed you can fix these teams for years and get away with it.

10) Do you still research for the illegal betting mafia?

Yes, everyday I get tips and do interviews. It is a huge problem all over the world.

11) Would you like to send a message to our Greek Attorney, Ms Papandreou (32 years old only) who took over the case and did what many men attorneys never wanted or could, do?

She is a hero and should be congratulated by everyone who cares about Greek sport.

12) I know that one very close youth friend of yours was Greek? Could you describe me please what is the picture that you have for Greeks and if you could marry your picture with the fact that Greece is so much involved in illegal betting?  

My best friend in High School was Greek. I visited Argos several times to see his family there. My Greek friends are honest, decent people who treated me like a second son. In those days they did not have a lot of money, but they gave me food, took me the hospital when I was sick and were very kind to me. I would not like to make any comparisons with them and the world of illegal gambling.

13) What do you thing is the best punishment for people who are arrested? Besides jail, sports punishments if their teams it’s necessary?

The people who fix matches should be banned for life from sport, no exceptions, no omissions. And we should take the time to explain to young players what a lifetime ban means – i.e,: they cannot even coach their children’s teams when they are playing in a match twenty-years on. Life means life. And a ban from all football means a ban from all, even amateur level, matches.

14) Would you recommend to  UEFA, banning all Greek teams from European tournaments?

No, I would not. I think that Greece should be praised for trying to take on corruption. If the teams and leagues, give up the people who may have been involved in corruption, than I think they should be allowed to play in Europe and show to the world what Greece can do, when it is not hamstrung with corruption.

**

Stay tuned. In a few days, a report on what it is like inside the political and bureaucratic halls of power as the fight gears up against match-fixing.

Share

Testimony of Dr. Declan Hill before the International Olympic Committee

Monday, February 28th, 2011

February 25, 2011

Lausanne, Switzerland

I cannot reveal the exact conversation of the International Olympic Committee members. Much of the meeting was confidential and I gave my word that their comments would remain off-the-record. However, I can say that there were seven of the top IOC executives at the private meeting at their headquarters in Lausanne. I was impressed at both the rank of the officials and the seriousness of their preparation. Almost all of the executives had read ‘The Fix’, there were several copies around the table, and we had a long and intense discussion about how to fight sports corruption. I do not know what will be the end result of the process towards an anti-corruption agency, but there was a seriousness and an attempt to listen that was encouraging.

The following is an excerpt of my speech to them and then an analysis of some of the key issues facing the formation of an international anti-corruption agency:

**

Ladies and Gentlemen,

We are facing an almost unprecedented threat to the future of sports. I have been to Asia. I have seen the effects of corruption on sports. I have seen the destruction of the credibility of sports – from Taiwanese baseball to Japanese sumo to Chinese football. I have seen the sports stadiums that used to be sold-out and that are now almost empty, thanks to match-fixing. I have studied the lucrative television and marketing rights that have now often been abandoned, thanks to match-fixing. I have seen the destruction of the dreams of hundreds-of-millions of players, coaches and fans, thanks to match-fixing. And, finally, I have seen the invasion of sports corruption into Africa, Europe and North America, as the effects of the globalized gambling market take hold of sports around the world.

We have already seen fixing at the Olympics. We all saw the events of the 2002 Winter Olympics with its involvement of Russian mafia godfathers, the FBI and the international embarrassment of two gold medals having to be presented for one event. We have already seen – in The Fix – that the Asian match-fixers were at the Athens Olympics in 2004. The fixers talked about it with me. The players talked about meeting them there. The players even spoke about accepting money from them for winning matches. So the fixers are already at the Olympics, and, so far, nothing effective has been done to stop them.

It is time to put away all the rivalries and cross-agendas in sport. I know that there are many personal and professional agendas in the sports world. I know that the private gambling companies may not like the public gambling companies and vice versa. I know that there are all kinds of divisions around anti-doping. But it is time to put those divisive issues aside, because we are facing a unique and rare challenge that behooves all of us to do things differently then we have ever done them before.

I began today’s presentation but saying that we were facing an almost unprecedented challenge to the future of sport. However, there was another time when corruption linked to match-fixing and gambling were threatening to destroy sport. It was a time when corruption was successfully fought off. It was the late 1880s and early 1890s. Our great-grandparents were facing the destruction of professional road-racing, rowing and cross-country running, along with a myriad of other sports, from match-fixing by professional gambling. The great Pierre de Coubertin created your very own organization, the foundation that built these walls, equipped this building and set fire to the imaginations of people around the world by forming the modern Olympic movement to fight those challenges. If that was the response of our forefathers, then we too can rise to the challenge. The corruption of world sport should not happen on our watch. It is our time, our generation’s challenge to fight against it and we should not fail.

**

What is the main issue for tomorrow’s (March 1st) meeting against match-fixing at the IOC?

i) There must be a credible working group created to tackle all sports corruption. It must include a broad range of people involved in the fight against corruption.

ii) A newly-established anti-corruption agency must fight against all forms of sports corruption, not just the sports gambling. Athletes when seeing corrupt sports officials, do not make a difference between gambling and other forms of corruption. Therefore,

iii) There must be a form of certification (similar to the ISO 9001 system) of every sports organization that wants to take part in international sports events. This method would ensure that all sports and national associations would be honestly-run.

Share

Comments on the IOC Sports Monitoring Unit

Monday, October 5th, 2009

For all media looking for thoughts on the announcement of the International Olympic Movement setting up a relationship with a commercial company to monitor irregular betting on sports events.

1)    A good start.

2)    Almost useless in protecting sport (See below).

Why?  Because the really bad boy fixers are still betting on the Asian illegal gambling market.  The monitoring unit is still mostly focused on the legal European and North American gambling sites.   This means that although they can monitor the live odds on an event, they cannot know which punters are making the odds change or the amount of money coming on to events with any precision.

Two, okay they discover irregular betting.  Now what?   Does this commercial company have detectives ready to investigate?   Does the IOC have an integrity unit ready to spring into action?   What sanctions are in place for athletes or their coaches, agents or family members if they are caught placing bets?  How can they be traced?

I did a study while at Oxford on ways that fixed football matches were detected, in less than 20% of the cases was the corruption detected by irregular odds changes.  So in all, this is a good start, but it does not go far enough.

Share