Posts Tagged ‘corruption’

The Week at FIFA

Monday, May 30th, 2011

It is difficult to overstate the incestuous world of FIFA. The place is a little like the Palace of Versailles in 1789 before the sans culottes dropped by: a closed, secretive place full of would-be Marie Antoinettes who do not one care about the media or public opinion. What we have seen in the last few days is unprecedented. The internal betrayals and media exposures by these top executives is extraordinary. A few thoughts on the story – journalists who are reading this note, please feel free to quote them in any of your articles:

1) The e-mail of Jérôme Valcke, the second in command at FIFA, to Jack Warner is astonishing. In the e-mail, Valcke states that he thinks that the Qataris bought the World Cup decision of 2022. This is very big news and cannot be underplayed in any way. If Valcke meant what he said, and there is no reason to suspect that he did not, this World Cup decision must be investigated. The decision of where to host the World Cup is the biggest in the sports business. It must be both clean, and seen to be clean.

2) Where are the sponsors? These scandals are deeply embarrassing. FIFA is in many ways the house that Adidas built. When will their senior executives, or Coke or Visa or any of the other large corporations who fund FIFA, intervene? They have to make a stand otherwise their money becomes tainted by an organization that, at this moment, has little credibility.

3) Where is Michel Platini? Here is an idea. Sponsors – get your act together – send a note to Platini and ask him to stand at the election. If you cannot get Platini ask a Noble Peace Prize winner – Lech Walesa, Martti Ahtisaari or even Al Gore. But get somebody with credibility and integrity who can step in and be a caretaker leader of FIFA until the football world gets its act together.

4) Finally, congratulations to Jens Weinreich and Andrew Jennings, they have been investigating and publishing stories on FIFA for over a decade. Few in the sports journalist community have wanted to believe them. They have been proved absolutely correct in their general assessment of the organization and some of its executives this week.

Share

About Time! (Or is it?)

Monday, January 3rd, 2011

RE: Blatter announces an anti-corruption group:

On January 2nd, the Swiss newspaper SonntagsZeitung printed an interview with Sepp Blatter, President of FIFA where he claimed that he is considering establishing an anti-corruption committee for FIFA. Great idea – on paper. However, as presented in the article, this is an idea which smacks of a publicity exercise rather than a genuine move to clean up the sport. I hope I am wrong, but here are a few questions and quotes for sports fans and journalists to consider:

1) Who are the investigators for this committee?

It is fine for Blatter to say that there will be “[people on the committee] not only from sport but from politics, finance, business and culture”. However, I do not see any professions with any credibility as investigators on that list. A good anti-corruption committee needs former police officers, gambling experts, prosecutors, lawyers and anti-corruption experts not a bunch of high-flyers with no investigative experience.

2) What is their budget?

Even the best investigators can do little if they have no money. Who will fund this group and by how much? I do not see an idea for a budget or a mandate – will they be able to travel to conduct proper interviews, or will they be scrounging for spare change for the bus?

3) How will it operate?

Will the committee actively investigate possible corruption among executives and match-fixers or wait until allegations are brought to it by the media?

4) Will their operations be separate from the rest of FIFA?

If not, it is a conflict of interest. You cannot investigate your boss. It will not work. If the structure is not set up to be completely independent of FIFA, how will it have any credibility?

5) Will the committee investigate the issues around the ISL bribery case?

According to a Swiss court, the case involved ISL paying bribes to a number of FIFA executives for the television rights of the World Cup tournaments in the 1990s. The BBC named three of those executives, but claimed there are also a number of other executives who may be involved. Will FIFA’s new anti-corruption committee investigate this case? If not, how will it have any credibility?

6) Finally, what will happen to any possible FIFA executives who are caught?

Just review what happened to Jack Warner – a senior FIFA executive member – after he was found guilty of essentially ticket touting by FIFA’s ethics committee. Will the anti-corruption committee be as toothless? If so, how will it have any credibility?

Share