On the first day of the World Cup, here is the transcript of my presentation before the Council of Europe. It is not about the World Cup, rather it is about something more important – the future of sport as we know it.
**
Testimony of Declan Hill, May 3, 2010
EPAS, The Council of Europe, Strasbourg
Mesdames et monsieurs, je vous remercie de l’invitation. C’est véritablement un honneur de faire une présentation pour vous aujourd’hui. En fait, c’est beaucoup plus important que simplement un honneur personnel. C’est très, très important. Parce que nous sommes engagé dans une guerre pour l’âme du sport. Pour dire vrai, nous ne sommes pas engagés dans une guerre. Mais l’ennemi est déjà ici. Et comme un cancer, il risque de détruire le sport Européen.
Ladies and Gentlemen, there has always been fixing and corruption in sport. Our friends from the Greek delegation can take us to the site of the ancient Olympics, built in 776 B.C. Outside that stadium were a whole collection of statues and shrines to the Gods. They were built with the fines levied on athletes and coaches who were caught cheating or fixing at the games. So corruption has had a long history in sport, back at least two-thousand eight-hundred years and that type of corruption will be with us for as long we continue to hold competitive sports. It is simply a part of human nature.
However, we of this generation – are facing something almost entirely new. It is a new form of match-fixing as if someone has taken fixing and injected it with steroids. It is an utterly modern phenomenon and it will destroy sport as we know it. We have spoken already this morning about governance in sport and youth in sport, but this new form of corruption will, like a Tsunami, sweep aside all these other issues and leave our sport dead and destroyed.
Those are big words and even bigger claims, and many of you may be sitting there thinking, ‘Who is this man and how can he make such wild allegations?’ It all sounds so extraordinary to a European, so I am going to spend the rest of my time here this morning going through the facts which lead me to make those claims. Many of these facts may be unknown to you, they will seem absolutely unbelievable to European ears, but I want to assure you that they are all absolutely true and that we are facing a very, very serious threat to all forms of European sports today.
I am, as our friend Sebastian was kind enough to say, an investigative journalist and have had the good fortune to win a number of national and international awards for my work. The research for the book was done over five years and featured interviews with over two-hundred and twenty people inside the sports world – players, referees, coaches, sports officials, policemen, prosecutors, bookmakers, professional gamblers and, most importantly, the fixers themselves. I spoke with match-fixers around the world about their means and methods. A group of Asian fixers brought me into meetings between them and coaches and players when they helped fix matches at the last World Cup. During these meetings I wore secret recording devices. However, it was not only this type of research that is the basis for my findings. It is also based on my doctoral thesis at the University of Oxford. To gain my degree I compiled and then analysed a whole range of statistical databases on fixed matches vs. non-fixed matches and players who were approached to fix games who either accepted or did not accept. So I speak this morning, partly as an investigator, partly as an academic.
If we take the entire sports gambling world at 100%, most of the forms that we are familiar with are relatively small. Las Vegas, for example, only has a small share of the total market, so let us add in the illegal sports gambling market of North America. This market is run by the LCN, or La Cosa Nostra, American organized crime. Let us add in the offshore gambling sites in Costa Rica and the Caribbean. Actually, let us also add in the big British gambling companies like Ladbrokes, William Hill and Betfair. We will even throw in the European sports national lotteries, run mostly by governments, that are comparative midgets in terms of sports gambling, but the only way of legally gambling on sports in many European countries. Combine all of those vastly different organizations and all their billions of Euro that they make in gross turn-over. Combine all of them into large pot and you only have 30-40% of the total world sports gambling market.
The rest is the Asian market. It is huge. It dwarfs the European and North American markets. And most of it is illegal, run by the equivalent of Al Capone. This is a vast, powerful market. Because much of it is illegal it is difficult to give an accurate estimate of its total size, but the American journal Foreign Policy tried to do that in 2006 when it estimated the total size of the Asian gambling market at $450 billion, for comparison, the size of the entire Asian pharmaceutical industry is roughly $100 billion.
What has happened is that this vast, illegal gambling market has corrupted sport across the continent of Asia. I do not want to exaggerate. There are a few Asian sports leagues that are corruption-free. The fixing in Japanese Sumo wrestling is so bad and so ritualized that it has even been featured in an academic article by the American economists Levitt and Duggan. The Taiwanese baseball league has had so many scandals linked to gambling match-fixing it has now been reduced to only four teams. Much of Asian sport is drenched in corruption. There is so much corruption in sport there, that to an outsider the stories just seem extraordinary, but here are a few examples:
The Chinese soccer league is a national disgrace. Those are the words of Chinese President Hu Jintao, who declared in the fall of 2009, that there was so much match-fixing and corruption in their soccer league that it embarrassed China. We see the same circumstances in the soccer leagues across the region: Vietnam, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Cambodia, Laos, Thailand, Malaysia and Singapore have all faced similar scandals in their own leagues. In Malaysia, the corruption was so bad that a cabinet minister there estimated that seventy percent of the matches in their leagues were corrupted. Seventy percent! That means it was more common for spectators to watch a corrupted match than a regularly played game. When there was an attempt to clean-up their extremely corrupt, joint Singaporean-Malaysian soccer league, the two countries came close to a diplomatic rift. The Malaysians claimed that the league was so corrupt because of the gamblers in Singapore were fixing a lot of the games; the Singaporeans said that the league was so corrupt because the criminals in Malaysia were fixing a lot of the games. Neither could agree so the league was disbanded because of the corruption.
The list of corruption stories in Asian sports goes on and on. The President of the Indonesian Football Association, the same people who recently tried an unsuccessful bid for the 2022 World Cup, was not just accused of corruption, he was not just charged with corruption, he was not just tried for corruption, but he was convicted and sentenced to 30-months in jail for corruption. However, at no point in that entire process did he ever resign or suspend himself from his post. In fact, he even continued to serve as President of the Indonesian FA and carried out its work from his prison cell. When he got out of prison he went on as the head of the Indonesian FA.
Possibly the best case that indicates the depth of corruption in Asian sport is the story of the South-East Asia Games of 2005. The South-East Asian Games are a kind of mini-Olympics of the region, with competitions in a range of athletics, team sports, etc. In November 2005, a few days before the tournament began the Vietnamese sports executive in charge of the team held a press conference. At the conference, the Vietnamese journalists expressed concern that their team was not particularly strong and would not win a lot of medals. “Don’t worry,” said the sports executive, “It is all fixed.” He then explained how many medals each national team would get and for which sports. Most of the Vietnamese press corps showed that independence of spirit that makes Communist regimes bastions of freethinking and democracy and did not report the story. However, one lonely AFP reporter at the press conference did write an article. It went out over the international wires where the Filipino journalists, who as a whole suffer from many problems but timidity is not one of them, splashed it all over their front pages. The Thai Prime Minister of the time Thaksin Shinawatra wearily responded when asked about these events at a press conference, that everyone knew that the SEA games were corrupt and they should think about abolishing the games. The Vietnamese government faced with a barrage of public embarrassment carefully reviewed the situation and realized what the problem was – the AFP reporter. So they pressured her to rescind her article. She apologized for ‘causing national embarrassment’ but did not withdraw the substance of her story.
At the end of the SEA Games in December 2005, two things happened. One, many Filipino journalists took great delight in pointing out that the medal tally of the games correlated exactly with the predictions of the Vietnamese sports executive. And two, eight Vietnamese soccer players were arrested for fixing matches with an international gambling ring.
Asian sports fans are not stupid. They know what is going on. They are not happy about all the corruption in their sports, in fact they are very angry. So what are they doing? They are turning their allegiances to teams in other leagues where they think the contests are not corrupt. This is part of the reason why you cannot walk down a street in China and not see three people wearing Manchester United shirts. However, far more importantly the punters in that vast illegal Asian gambling market are switching their bets from the local soccer leagues, with all the corruption in them, to European leagues. They are betting on all measures of matches from the big, prestigious Champions League all the way down to tiny games in second division Women’s Soccer in the Netherlands.
There are a number of companies organizing monitors who go to matches across Europe. They send people to the sidelines of these games where they stand with their mobile phones or laptops reporting back to the illegal gambling market in Shanghai or Johor Bahru or Manila. Again, they are not just reporting on the big English Premier League, or La Liga or Serie A games. In July 2008, in Copenhagen, Denmark there was the annual Tivoli Cup. The Tivoli Cup is a youth tournament for teams across Denmark aged 11 to 19. It is a big tournament, but most matches are played in parks and watched by a couple of dozen people, mostly parents and that year some of the coaches for the teams found four Chinese gambling monitors reporting on the games back to the Asian bookmakers. To repeat, the illegal gambling market in Asia is so powerful that it is worthwhile to monitor games of Danish teenagers playing matches in a park.
This is why I get phone calls every few weeks from journalists in a whole range of different countries – Belgium, Finland, Germany, Switzerland, South Korea, – all asking, essentially the same question, “These are such small games in our smallest leagues, we don’t care about these games, why should someone come thousands of miles around the world to fix them?”
What are the Asian fixers doing? They too are not stupid and they are trying to do to European leagues what they so successfully did in their own leagues – corrupt them. Now the fixers are coming to Europe and forming alliances with local criminals. It is an ideal marriage. The Asian criminals get access to the teams and players; the European criminals get access to the lucrative Asian gambling market.
We know that they have been fixing games in a range of different countries – across the continent. Recently, the German organized crime squad in Bochum, announced that they suspected over two-hundred matches, ranging from Champions League matches to youth games across Europe may have been fixed.
The range of European countries that have had fixing scandals in football in recent years is a long one. Here is an incomplete list: Turkey, Greece, Belgium, Switzerland, Germany, Austria, Croatia, Slovakia, Czech Republic, Poland (where one cabinet minister, like his Malaysian counterpart, estimated that over 70% of the games had been fixed), Russia, Romania, Bulgaria, Macedonia, Cyprus, Malta, Italy, Bosnia, Finland, Portugal. I could go on, but I won’t. I am not here to make people uncomfortable. I am not here to embarrass any one nation. I am not here to single out one group or country and say they are worse than others. However, I do stand before you as a man who has risked his life to protect a sport that he loves. Five years ago when I spoke about these dangers many people did not believe me, “It is not possible,” they said, “that so much corruption could come into our sports.” Now many of those same people have passed from disbelief to resignation without going through combat. They say things like, “It is not possible to do anything about all this corruption, and besides it is not the big teams or the big players.” This is the attitude of the deliberately blind. It also avoids the question – What happens in five years? Star players do not emerge fully-grown from the ground. Many players on big teams in the big leagues come from the very teams and leagues that have now been shown to be corrupt. So they are wrong. They were wrong to deny the problem five years ago. They are wrong to refuse to fight now to protect their sport and they are wrong to say, ‘there is nothing we can do’.
There is much that we can do. We can establish integrity units in each national sport association across Europe. We can establish an International Anti-corruption Agency, funded in part by the gambling industry but separate from them, which can collect information and help launch investigations. An Anti-corruption Agency that would have the same purpose and structure as the World Anti-doping Agency. We can establish proper training and teaching of young players – as they come into the game they can learn the sad truth that if they sell games to these fixers, they become in effect their slaves. We can establish proper pensions and educational benefits for the players. We can establish anti-corruption hotlines for players and referees to report corrupt approaches. There are literally dozens of easy, doable and effective ways of stopping the wide-scale corruption
It is, then, possible to protect European sport. It is actually very easy to protect European sport. It has become the vessel for many of our hopes and dreams in our societies, so we should clean up sport. There are many, many things that we can do to protect sport, so we can clean up sport. And for the sake of our young people and all those come after us, we must clean up sport.
Tags: gambling, match fixing, sports journalism, world cup
I would love it if you could/would post a list of WC matches you believe were fixed. I’d love to generate some discussion on each match in question. This should be an ongoing process.
If more fans become better educated on the finer points of match fixing, perhaps we could exert greater pressure on FIFA to deal with the problem.
Read “The Fix” a year ago…and just watched the France vs. Mexico game. My goodness this game look VERY suspicious!! At first it didn’t even cross my mind, and I just thought France were playing awfully. But I’ve never seen Patrice Evra not try to get up the pitch at least once in a match nor have I seen him get beat by wingers so easily. He’s one of the best defenders in the world and he’s got beat by a Mexican league players? Gallas letting players shoot in the box without even an once of effort to stop them? Abidal taking the Mexican out in the box even though he’s been in that position hundreds of times before and knew the player was going nowhere with the ball? Or how about the overall lack of urgency by the French in the second half? No movement off the ball. None. Professional players move off the ball in their sleep and they looked in the replays not to care about moving around in the Mexican half in the slightest. WOW!!!!!!
Dear Readers,
Crikey! The tournament is only a week old and I have been swamped with e-mails and tweets asking about fixes. So first, I don’t think Robert Green was on the fix. It looked to me like simply a case of the new ball, nerves and that the poor fellow did not have anything to do for a long time and then suddenly there was a shot on goal.
As for the fixes, you know when the red-flag games are coming up. They will be in the third games of the first round.
Fight to keep the beautiful game clean, it is worth it.
Declan
I am a former ice hockey referee; as a sports official myself, I am always willing to give officials the benefit of the doubt. However, there is no excuse for the disgraceful exhibition of “refereeing” perpetrated by Koman Coulibaly. His flagrantly bad call against the US squad in the disallowing the likely winning goal certainly raises a red flag about the integrity of that match. So too does the abominable job of refereeing in the game that preceded the US-Slovenia game, and the officiating in the Brazil-Ivory Coast game falls into the same category.
Sepp Blatter’s lame excuse that he likes the “debate” and the “subjectivity” that are generated by the lack of transparency and public accountability in FIFA officiating certainly leads one to question how serious he really is about protecting the integrity of the game, doesn’t it? How on earth can he justify this horrendous officiating in the belief that it is good for the game? The LAST thing any game official should be is “subjective,” because, as in the case of Koman Coulibaly, it leads to all manner of suspicion about his motive for disallowing the US goal at such a critical moment of the game. Was he merely incompetent? Does he have a personal or political bias against the US team for reasons known only to himself, which led him to decide that he was not going to allow the US to win that game? Or was he bought off by the outside interests that you have worked so hard to expose? Was that game fixed?????
Is THIS the type of “debate” that Blatter wants to encourage as a means of growing the game?? If so, he needs to be ousted as head of FIFA ASAP.
This game needs a good dose of OBJECTIVITY, and that would be achieved through the selective use of instant replay in exactly the type of circumstance surrounding the disallowed goal in the US-Slovenia game. Video replay has been successfully implemented in the National Hockey League in order to OBJECTIVELY determine whether a goal has been scored when it cannot be determined in real time. And I think the game is unquestionably better for it. Another improvement in ice hockey officiating has been the use of a second referee. Since players have been getting bigger, stronger and faster, it has become increasingly difficult for one person to keep up with the demands of refereeing the game. The addition of a second referee provides not only a second set of eyes, but also acts as a counterbalance against biased officiating on the part of one’s partner. And–if nothing else, the presence of a second referee would put a serious (and welcome) dent in the incidence of “diving,” such as the ludicrous dive in today’s Brazil-Ivory Coast game which resulted in a red card for Kaka. That makes a mockery of the game. I think it’s high time that FIFA gave serious consideration to adding a second referee on the pitch along with judicious use of video replay.